Categories
Human Behavior Life Lessons

The Case Against Empathy, Part Two

I was walking on the High Line, the elevated park and tourist destination on Manhattan’s West Side, when I almost tripped over two women in front of me. They had spotted a lanternfly on the ground. Lanternflies are really pretty when you see them, with soft gray wings dotted with black spots that open to a flash of red underneath, which is probably one of the evolutionary keys to their success. The women looked at it carefully and found a small leaf. They didn’t want to touch it, so they used the leaf to gracefully scoop it up and put it in the garden along the side of the path. It was a sign of love and affection.

What I wanted to do was step on it. That’s what I’m supposed to do. Lanternflies turned up on Staten Island in 2020, and the next summer the Parks Department told us to kill them. “If you see a spotted lanternfly, please squish and dispose of this invasive pest.” Lanternflies come from China. They feed on the sap of trees and grapevines. They have almost no natural predators, so there’s nothing to stop them but us.

But I was in a rush. I was on my phone, and it looked like they didn’t speak English. If I stepped on it, I would in some way be the worst person in the world, killing a bug they thought was beautiful. And I couldn’t explain to them why it was the right thing to do to keep our community beautiful. So I kept walking and left the lanternfly on its leaf. I had just aided and abetted them in destroying the New York City parks they were loving walking through.

The whole thing reminded me of a fake Mercedes commercial some German film students made in 2013. A new Mercedes rolls through a foggy village that looks like the late 1800s. Two little girls run into the road, and the car’s collision-prevention system stops it just in time. Further on, a boy is flying a kite. The car speeds up and hits him, and his mother screams, “Adolf!” Then the car passes the town sign for Braunau am Inn, and the tagline comes up, “Detects dangers before they arise.” I feel for the little boy, and the best thing for the car to do would have been, of course, to save him. But then again, it’s Hitler.

Further Reading

This is a follow-up to The Case Against Empathy, where I wrote about watching an insect chew a leaf until it looked like lace and realizing that empathy isn’t always a good thing. Both posts grew out of Paul Bloom’s Against Empathy. He describes empathy as a spotlight. It helps us zero in on one specific tiny thing while ignoring everything else.


Discover more from Rob Schlaff's Website

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.