Categories
Media

The Loneliest Poem

I don’t read much poetry these days. Mostly it happens when I help out with homework, or when friends organize a literary workshop. What I love is the moment a poem turns out to have a second meaning under the first, and then a third under that.

Recently my son had to write about Edgar Allan Poe’s “Alone” for English. This stuff is hard, so on a Tuesday night he wanted to sit with me at the kitchen table and talk it through. We ended up talking about what it’s like to be alone. On the surface “Alone” is a simple poem about a lonely young man, but it turned into a rabbit hole. Every time I thought I’d hit the bottom of its loneliness, there was a lonelier level underneath. It’s only twenty-two lines, so you can read it here, or listen to one of the many people who have read it aloud on YouTube.

From childhood’s hour I have not been
As others were — I have not seen
As others saw — I could not bring
My passions from a common spring —
From the same source I have not taken
My sorrow — I could not awaken
My heart to joy at the same tone —
And all I lov’d — I lov’d alone —
Then — in my childhood — in the dawn
Of a most stormy life — was drawn
From ev’ry depth of good and ill
The mystery which binds me still —
From the torrent, or the fountain —
From the red cliff of the mountain —
From the sun that ’round me roll’d
In its autumn tint of gold —
From the lightning in the sky
As it pass’d me flying by —
From the thunder, and the storm —
And the cloud that took the form
(When the rest of Heaven was blue)
Of a demon in my view —

Level 1: Lonelier than the lunch table

My son opens with the idea that most people think loneliness means sitting by yourself at lunch or having nobody to talk to, but sometimes it means feeling that nobody understands you even when you’re surrounded by people. That’s the loneliness in this poem. The speaker never says anyone left him out. Instead he keeps listing what he has not done and could not do, “I have not been,” “I have not seen,” “I could not bring,” “I could not awaken.” My son noticed how those negatives pile up into an inventory of every way the speaker can’t experience life like other people, and how the repetition makes the loneliness feel permanent, there since childhood.

Level 2: As a child, Poe was abandoned

Poe had reasons. His father walked out when he was a baby, and his mother died of tuberculosis when he was two. The children were split up, and Edgar went to John and Frances Allan in Richmond, who gave him his middle name but never adopted him. Frances doted on him. John Allan fought with him for years, mostly about money. In February 1829 Frances died, and Poe, away in the army, arrived the day after she was buried. That’s the same year he wrote “Alone.” When he writes “From childhood’s hour I have not been / As others were,” he isn’t exaggerating much.

Level 3: Alone even in love

The poem goes deeper than a sad biography, though. Even love doesn’t help. “And all I lov’d — I lov’d alone,” he writes. Love is supposed to be the way out of loneliness, and he does even that by himself. Irvin Yalom, the existential psychiatrist, calls this existential isolation, the gap between any one person and everyone else that no relationship ever fully closes. A better childhood wouldn’t have closed it. Even in love, the speaker is standing on his own side of that gap.

Level 4: A terrible gift

The second half of the poem shows how differently he sees. He draws “From ev’ry depth of good and ill,” and the images swing from the red cliff and the sun’s “autumn tint of gold” to lightning, thunder, storm, and finally a demon in an otherwise blue sky. My son noticed how the mood turns from warmth to fear. Poe sees the world brighter in some places and darker in others than the people around him, and that’s a blessing and a curse. It makes him a poet, and it keeps him on his own. My son called it a terrible gift.

That’s where my son’s paper ended, and where I started looking things up.

Level 5: Alone in a book of love poems

Poe wrote the poem around 1829 in the autograph album of a young Baltimore woman named Lucy Holmes, born in 1809, the same year he was. Her friends filled it with 76 poems and drawings across 258 pages between 1826 and 1848. According to the Maryland Center for History and Culture, which holds the album, most of those poems seem to have been written to court her. Poe headed his own page “Original” and signed it “E. A. Poe,” and he also copied out a poem of his brother’s, at his brother’s request. Nobody knows whether he wrote “Original” for Lucy or brought along something he already had. Either way, in a book full of people trying to win someone’s heart, Poe wrote about loving alone.

Page 55 of Lucy Holmes’s album, about 1829. Maryland Center for History and Culture, MS 1796.

Level 6: Unseen, renamed, and doubted

Poe never published it, and he died in 1849. The poem didn’t appear until the September 1875 Scribner’s Monthly, after a writer named Eugene L. Didier found it in the album and had it printed as a facsimile of the handwritten page. Didier had retouched the photograph, adding a title, “Alone,” and a date he guessed at. The title stuck, and the retouching backfired. John Henry Ingram, one of Poe’s early biographers, called the poem a forgery, and as late as 1888 he filed it under “Doubtful.” The question wasn’t settled until 1950, when a scholar named Irby Bruce Cauthen Jr. looked at the actual album. So after forty-six years out of sight, the poem about not belonging spent the next seventy-five proving it belonged.

Didier’s retouched facsimile in Scribner’s Monthly, September 1875. The title and date line are his.

Level 7: Poe was more famous in French

Poe wasn’t ignored at home. “The Raven” had made him famous in America, though his reputation there was fought over. In France, Charles Baudelaire took him up with something close to devotion. He published his first Poe translation in 1848, while Poe was alive, and almost everything else, a long essay and volumes of translations, came after Poe died. Baudelaire wrote that he meant to make Poe “un grand homme pour la France,” a great man for France, and he described finding in Poe stories and poems he’d half-imagined himself, which Poe had gone ahead and finished.

Level 8: Alone together, again

Lucy’s granddaughter gave the album to the Maryland Historical Society in 1969, and sometime in the 1990s the society removed Poe’s two pages and catalogued them on their own, as MS 1796. Photocopies hold their places in the album, among the poems and drawings of Lucy’s friends. So the poem that sat alone in a book of courtship has now been taken out of the book entirely, which would be the loneliest level yet if it weren’t for the page beside it. The other page in MS 1796 is the one Edgar copied out because his brother asked him to, a poem called “I have gazed on woman’s cheek.” They’re alone, but they’re alone together.

There’s an irony here. Even with eight levels of loneliness, this feeling of aloneness brings us all together. Almost everyone has felt that nobody understood why something mattered to them, or that everyone else was happy about something they couldn’t enjoy. My son put it best when he wrote that the feeling that nobody understands us is itself something many people understand. Nobody understands me. Everybody understands that. So here we are, alone together, like Edgar’s page and his brother’s.

Further Reading

The Maryland Center for History and Culture has the record for Poe’s page, the whole album, and a blog post on the courtship poems.


Discover more from Rob Schlaff's Website

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.